For nonprofits, the holiday season is one of the most important fundraising opportunities of the year, and GivingTuesday, the global day of generosity held on the Tuesday after Thanksgiving, has become a major part of that opportunity.

Positioned immediately after Black Friday and Cyber Monday, it shifts the focus from spending to giving and creates a natural moment for nonprofits to connect with people who are already thinking about how they can make a difference. And the momentum is significant. In 2025, 38.1 million Americans participated, contributing $4 billion in just 24 hours, a 13% increase over the previous year.

Capitalizing on the season shouldn’t be limited to GivingTuesday, however. For nonprofits, it can be the beginning of a larger holiday appeal that builds momentum through December and turns seasonal generosity into longer-lasting support.

Why GivingTuesday matters.

One of GivingTuesday’s biggest advantages is that nonprofits don’t have to create the moment themselves. The awareness, conversation, and sense of urgency are already there. People see GivingTuesday messages in their inboxes, social feeds, and communities. They see friends supporting organizations they care about. They hear companies and community leaders talking about giving back.

All that attention gives individual nonprofits an opportunity to tell their own stories within a much larger movement and take advantage of several key benefits:

It offers an alternative to the holiday shopping frenzy. After days focused on Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals, GivingTuesday creates a natural shift toward generosity. It gives people an opportunity to balance what they’ve spent with what they can give.

It can introduce your organization to new supporters. Shared hashtags, social activity, community campaigns, and peer-to-peer fundraising can put your mission in front of people who may never have encountered your organization otherwise.

It creates urgency. A defined 24-hour campaign gives people a reason to act now instead of telling themselves they’ll donate eventually.

It expands the definition of giving. Participation doesn’t have to mean making a monetary donation. In 2025, 11.1 million Americans volunteered on GivingTuesday, while 20.9 million used their voices to support causes. Volunteering, sharing a campaign, donating goods, or encouraging friends to participate can all deepen someone’s connection to an organization.

Don’t stop on Wednesday.

One of the biggest mistakes a nonprofit can make is treating GivingTuesday as an isolated fundraising event. The weeks that follow are just as important.

Year-end fundraising represents a significant portion of annual giving for many nonprofits. Some organizations receive between 24% and 47% of their annual revenue during November and December, and roughly 12% of annual charitable giving can occur during the final three days of the year alone.

That means your GivingTuesday campaign can serve as the first chapter of a larger story. Someone may see your GivingTuesday social post but not donate. Then they receive an email the following week featuring someone your organization helped. Later, they see a progress update. Finally, your year-end appeal gives them another opportunity to act.

Each interaction helps build familiarity, understanding, and trust. So instead of thinking, “How do we raise as much as possible on GivingTuesday?” ask, “How can we use GivingTuesday to start a conversation that continues through the end of the year and beyond?”

Give people a reason to care.

During the holidays, donors are hearing from a lot of organizations. Simply saying “Please donate” isn’t enough to stand out. Potential donors need to quickly understand three things: why the need matters, what their gift can accomplish, and why now is the right time to help.

The most effective appeals connect the ask to the impact. Show supporters what their contribution makes possible. Instead of focusing only on what your organization needs, explain what the donor can help accomplish.

A $50 donation may provide meals for a family. A $100 gift may help provide supplies for a classroom. A contribution toward a capital campaign might bring a community organization one step closer to opening a new facility.

Stories make those numbers meaningful. Use real people, authentic photography, testimonials, and short-form video to show the impact behind your mission. A 30-second video featuring someone your organization has helped can often communicate more than a graphic filled with statistics.

Create more motivation with a matching gift.

If possible, secure a matching donor before your holiday campaign begins. A board member, major donor, corporate partner, or local business may be willing to match contributions up to a certain amount, giving supporters the opportunity to double the impact of their gifts.

That can be a powerful motivator. Research has found that mentioning matching gifts in an appeal can increase response rates by 71% and average donation amounts by 51%.

A match also gives you another compelling message to build your campaign around: Give today and your gift goes twice as far. And when you add a deadline or fundraising goal, you create even more urgency.

Make your appeals personal.

The same message shouldn’t necessarily go to everyone on your list. A longtime donor has a different relationship with your organization than someone who signed up for your email newsletter last month. A recurring donor may respond to a message about increasing their impact, while a lapsed donor may need a reminder of why they supported you in the first place.

Segmenting your communications lets you acknowledge those differences. Consider tailoring emails and other outreach based on factors such as past giving, donation frequency, volunteer participation or previous campaign engagement.

Even small touches, such as referencing a donor’s past support, can make an appeal feel less like a mass fundraising blast and more like a continuation of an existing relationship.

Put your supporters to work, too.

Your nonprofit isn’t the only one that can tell your story. Board members, volunteers, employees, and loyal donors can become some of your strongest advocates.

Give them the tools to share your campaign with their own networks. That could include sample social posts, campaign graphics, short videos, suggested email copy, and direct links to your donation page.

Peer-to-peer outreach brings an added layer of credibility because the message is coming from someone the potential donor already knows and trusts. It also helps extend the reach of your campaign far beyond your organization’s own followers.

Remove friction from the donation process.

Once someone decides to give, don’t make them work for it. Your donation experience should be fast, simple, and easy to complete on a phone.

Before your campaign launches, test the entire process yourself. Does the page load quickly? Is the donate button obvious? Are you asking only for information you actually need? Can supporters use convenient payment options such as PayPal or digital wallets?

Every unnecessary click or form field gives a potential donor another opportunity to abandon the process.

Keep the conversation going.

The end of a fundraising campaign shouldn’t be the end of your communication. Thank people. Tell them what happened. Share how much was raised, what that support will make possible, and what comes next. And continue communicating with new donors throughout the year.

GivingTuesday itself increasingly emphasizes that generosity is bigger than a single day, and the same idea should guide your nonprofit’s marketing. A first-time donor in December has the potential to become a volunteer, advocate, recurring donor, or longtime supporter, but only if you continue building the relationship.

For more than 30 years, Creative Spot has helped nonprofits make the most of moments like GivingTuesday and year-end appeals while building stronger marketing programs all year long. From campaign strategy and messaging to creative, digital, social, and more, we help organizations connect with the right audiences, inspire action, and move closer to their fundraising and mission goals.

If you’d like to discuss how we can help your organization make the most of your next campaign, get in touch with us here.